Introduction
Something I have always appreciated about both the Gospel of John and 1 John is that both books have a clear purpose statement. Have you ever listened to someone go on and on and jump from this thing to that thing, and all you can think is, “What’s the point?” You don’t have to wonder with John. No, John 20:31 says, “These have been written so that you may believe that Jesus is the Christ, the Son of God; and that believing you may have life in His name.”
John wrote this book to demonstrate that Jesus is “the Christ, the Son of God” and to persuade you to believe on him. Remember that today. We are going to look at Jesus’ trial before Pilate. It’s another fascinating twist in the most precious story of our faith. But remember, this story is about Jesus. And it is about Pilate. He met Jesus, he was confronted with his glory, and he had a choice to make. Tragically he did not believe (Read Text).
What a tragedy. Pilate came face to face with King Jesus, but he doesn’t see him for who he is. Don’t make the same the mistake. Honor Jesus as the sovereign king. That said, let’s walk step by step through this story. Verse 28 establishes…
I. The Setting (v. 28)
Last week, we looked at Jesus informal trial before Annas. John quickly notes that from there Jesus had a more formal Jewish trial before Caiaphas and the Sanhedrin. The other Gospels say it was a humiliating sham. “Now the chief priests and the whole Council kept trying to obtain false testimony against Jesus, so that they might put Him to death. They did not find any, even though many false witnesses came forward” (Matt 26:59–60).
Exasperated, Caiaphas finally asked Jesus directly if he were the “Christ, the Son of God.” Jesus said he was, and Caiaphus declared him deserving of death. “Then they spat in His face and beat Him with their fists; and others slapped Him, and said, ‘Prophesy to us, You Christ; who is the one who hit You’” (Matt 26:67–68)?
But Rome did not permit the Jews to execute criminals. I know they will kill Stephen, but that was illegal. This time, they submit. They march Jesus over to the Roman Praetorium, or fortress in Jerusalem.
Pilate lived in Caesarea, and normally, the Jews would have to bring Jesus there to try and execute him (That’s where the Romans will try Paul). But in God’s providence (which never fails) and to fulfill prophecy, Pilate was in Jerusalem and the Passion unfolds according to all that God had said. God rules every detail. That includes your details.
So, the Jews marched Jesus over to the Praetorium. BTW, archaeologists are aware of two fortresses in Jerusalem that Herod the Great had built. Pilate could have been at either one. I want to keep pounding the table for the fact that this is not an imaginary tale. Jesus really lived, died, and rose again.
But the Jews don’t want to enter the Praetorium because they want to remain clean for the Passover. The Passover was of the previous night, but it kicked off the Feast of Unleavened Bread for 7 more days. The Sanhedrin don’t want to miss any of the festivities. Because of that, our text takes place in 3 scenes. Pilate will start outside with the Sanhedrin, go inside with Jesus, then outside with the mob. So, the first scene is outside between…
II. Pilate and the Sanhedrin (vv. 29–32)
John uses this scene to tell you 2 truths about the Savior whom he wants you to trust for salvation and then for all of life. First…
Jesus was innocent. Our story begins early in the morning, probably around 6 a.m. Pilate gets word that the Sanhedrin are outside with a criminal suspect. Pilate marches out, and asks, “What accusation do you bring against this Man?” God cares about justice, and at least in principle so did the Romans. Pilate will falter, but he asks a question that is vital to your faith in Jesus—was Jesus guilty or was he innocent?
The Jews’ reply is comically weak (v. 30). They’re standing before a Roman governor. They’ve been plotting this day for months. The best they can do is “trust us”! They are really hoping for a kangaroo court.
That’s because their concern is theological. Jesus claimed to be the Son of God. Caiaphas declared this blasphemy punishable by death. (Of course, Jesus is the Son of God, so it’s not blasphemy). But Caiaphas is convinced it is. However, Pilate couldn’t care less about blasphemy.
The Jews know that. They hope Pilate will accept a vague reply, but Pilate is not buying it. So, he retorts, “Take Him yourselves, and judge Him according to your law.” He sees this is a religious matter, and I’m sure he thought the Jews and all their theological scruples were very strange. He has no time for that. It’s obvious to him that Jesus has not committed a capital crime.
And this would have had tremendous apologetic significance for John’s original readers who associated crucifixion with the worst of the worst. So, John demonstrates that Jesus did not deserve that stigma. His only crime was declaring the truth that he was the Son of God.
Jesus did not die for his sins; he died for yours. No one took his life; he laid it down for you. Jesus was innocent. But his innocence was not weakness. This conversation also demonstrates that…
Jesus is sovereign. Pilate told the Jews to judge Jesus themselves, but they reply, “We are not permitted to put anyone to death.” They don’t just want Jesus punished; they want him dead!
And John sees God’s sovereign hand of providence behind this (v. 32). John is referring to John 12:32–33. Jesus predicted his crucifixion, that he would be “lifted up” on a cross. He also said, “As Moses lifted up the serpent in the wilderness, even so must the Son of Man be lifted up; so that whoever believes will in Him have eternal life” (John 3:14–15).
That’s significant because the Law said that blasphemy, the Jews’ accusation against Jesus, was punishable by stoning. Occasionally, the Jews hung people, but it wasn’t common (turn?). “If a man has committed a sin worthy of death and he is put to death, and you hang him on a tree, his corpse shall not hang all night on the tree, but you shall surely bury him on the same day (for he who is hanged is accursed of God), so that you do not defile your land which the Lord your God gives you as an inheritance” (Deut 21:22–23).
This statute perfectly set the stage for Jesus’ crucifixion. We stand under God’s curse, so Jesus became our curse by hanging on a tree. Therefore, he can rescue you from God’s curse when you receive him by faith. It is marvelous!
And John says it also highlights Jesus’ sovereignty. The Jews thought they were in charge. Pilate definitely thought he was in charge, but all of them were pawns in God’s plan to get Jesus to the cross. Jesus looked meek and mild, but his quiet hand of providence guided every step.
Jesus is not just a great moral teacher or a prophet. He is the Christ, the Son of God. He demands your worship, and he is worthy of all your trust. Believe on him for salvation. Then consider your life and your circumstances. This little interaction between the Sanhedrin and Pilate looked like a random conversation, but God was pressing his sovereign will. God is doing the same with you. God is moving even if you can’t see it. Nothing is random. Jesus is sovereign. Returning to our text, Pilate has heard enough. Then he moves inside for the 2nd scene between…
III. Pilate and Jesus (vv. 33–38a)
John is filled with powerful conversations—Jesus with Nicodemus, the Samaritan woman, Mary Magdalene, and others. This one is right there at the top. Pilate thinks he is going to interrogate Jesus, but the Savior masterfully turns the tables and presses Pilate. He comes face to face with King Jesus. We’re left to wonder will he believe, or will he refuse?
But Pilate thinks he’s the interrogator. He asks, “Are You the King of the Jews?” Apparently, the Sanhedrin accused Jesus of being an insurrectionist who claimed to a king. It makes sense because Pilate didn’t care about theological differences, but he would care about someone undermining Rome. So, he asks, “Are You the King of the Jews?”
Jesus replies, “Are you saying this on your own initiative, or did others tell you about Me?” Jesus is so wise. He doesn’t say just “yes” because the answer is complicated. Jesus is a king, but not the kind Pilate meant. So, Jesus turns the question on Pilate.
But he’s also so loving. He sees past Pilate the interrogator to Pilate the image bearer who needs salvation. Jesus is not evading the question; he is probing Pilate’s heart—“Pilate, what do you believe?”
That’s so good. So often we think evangelism is merely sharing a gospel outline. At some point, that’s necessary. But a good question that makes a person face his own emptiness or foolish beliefs is a great place to start. What do you believe? What do you want out of life? What is ultimate truth?
Jesus is graciously probing Pilate’s beliefs. But sadly, Pilate is apathetic and annoyed. He retorts, “I am not a Jew, am I? Your own nation and the chief priests delivered You to me; what have You done?” Have you ever tried to share the gospel with someone like Pilate? You raise an issue of the highest importance—death, eternity, or truth—but this person refuses to go there.
Many people hate discussing religion, or they are fine as long as you stick to vague generalities like God and faith, but they are terrified of the truth and their own lack of conviction. Maybe you are a Pilate. Religion scares you. Talking about your faith scares you. I understand. Faith is a lot to face, but don’t turn a blind eye when your soul is at stake. You must face the question—what do you believe about Jesus?
Sadly, Pilate refuses. He fights to remain the interrogator. He asks by asking, “What have you done?” Why does the Sanhedrin want you dead? Jesus gives another winsome reply (v. 36). First, Jesus addresses Pilate’s concern. “Pilate, if I’m an insurrectionist, where’s the insurrection? Neither I nor my followers have done anything to undermine Rome. I’m not a threat.”
But Jesus won’t let Pilate off the spiritual hook. Pilate wants to focus on earthly kingdoms, but Jesus presses him to consider a far greater spiritual kingdom where Jesus is the king. Maybe you love this world. It’s comfortable because you can understand it, see it, and touch it. But this world is just a passing shadow. You will die and after this the judgment. You must deal with Christ’s coming kingdom.
Sadly, Pilate is only focused on the moment. He only cares about doing his job. He replies, “So You are a king?” He doesn’t believe Jesus is a king, but he’s playing along with this religious fanatic.
But Jesus presses Pilate again (v. 37b). That is a powerful statement. First, Jesus confronts Pilate with the fact that he is the King. Jesus born to reign.
“For a child will be born to us, a son will be given to us; and the government will rest on His shoulders; and His name will be called Wonderful Counselor, Mighty God, Eternal Father, Prince of Peace. There will be no end to the increase of His government or of peace, on the throne of David and over his kingdom, to establish it and to uphold it with justice and righteousness from then on and forevermore (Isa 9:6–7).
Jesus came the first time as a lamb to die for our sins, but he was born to reign. Jesus is the king. Someday, he will reign over this world from the throne of David. You must believe that Jesus is your king. You can pretend you’re your own king, and it might be a fun dream, but it is not reality.
Jesus is coming again to judge the world. He will judge you. Then he will establish a just, righteous, and good kingdom for all who believe on him. It’s going to be an awful day for all who have rebelled against his reign, but it will be the happiest day for all who have bowed the knee.
So, John leaves us to wonder, will Pilate bow the knee to king Jesus? Have you bowed the knee to king Jesus?
Then Jesus declares that he is the truth. He was born “to testify to the truth.” This is an important theme to John. “Grace and truth were realized through Jesus Christ. No one has seen God at any time; the only begotten God who is in the bosom of the Father, He has explained Him” (John 1:17–18).
In the internet age, it’s not hard to find a lot of falsehood. With AI, you can’t even be sure some pictures are real. But Jesus is the truth. He is the perfect revelation of God who is ultimate truth. Nothing is more precious than to know God and be right with him.
So, Jesus lovingly presents himself to Pilate as the king of creation and the ultimate truth. Will Pilate see the truth and believe? Sadly, he shut down the conversation with a curt, dismissive question, “What is truth?”
Pilate is not trying to make some grand philosophical assertion of postmodernism because he immediately walked away. I wish Jesus had a chance to reply because I would love to hear what he would have said. But Pilate doesn’t care. He stared ultimate truth in the face, and tragically he ignored it.
Don’t make the same mistake. Right now you are coming face to face with Jesus in his Word. You may respect Jesus and respect what you are hearing, but it’s much easier to go eat lunch and watch football than to deal with the truth in front of you. It’s easier to live in the gray of relativism than to look truth and falsehood in the face.
That’s where most of our world is. “What is truth” could be a mantra for Western culture. It lets everyone imagine they are sovereign over their own lives and can make up their own truth. But it’s nonsense, and everyone knows it. Truth is truth, and you can’t imagine or feel it into something different. Ultimate truth is in your Creator, Jesus Christ. So, behold him.
If you’ve never been saved, confess that Jesus is Lord and receive him as Savior. If you are saved, keep your eyes on the king. Anchor all of life, your values, your purpose, your hope, everything to Christ. Look to him for grace today and invest in the coming kingdom of Christ. Live for eternity.
Well, Pilate failed the test. He fled the Savior and headed outside. The final scene is between…
IV. Jesus and the mob (vv. 38b–40)
Pilate does not believe, but he doesn’t think Jesus is guilty either. So, Luke tells us that he sent Jesus to Herod, hoping he’d take a sticky situation off his hands. Herod mocked Jesus and put the purple robe on him. Then he sent Jesus right back to Pilate.
That’s where John picks up with a tragic scene between Pilate and the mob. Pilate begins with a crucial declaration, “I find no guilt in Him.” Pilate thought Jesus was crazy, but he wasn’t a criminal. John wanted his Greek and Roman readers to know that the Roman governor declared Jesus, “not guilty.” That’s important. Jesus did not need to die for his sins; he needed to die for yours.
So, in God’s providence Pilate was a weak leader who didn’t stand for justice. Instead, he played politics and looked for a way to please everyone. None of this is an accident. God is accomplishing his sovereign will.
Therefore, instead of standing on conviction and releasing Jesus, Pilate grasped for a convenient solution and offered to release Jesus based on an annual Passover tradition.
We don’t know much about this tradition, but apparently as an act of good will toward the Jews, Rome would release a prisoner the Jews wanted to be free. Pilate really hoped the crowd would want Jesus, so he offers, “Do you want me to release to you the king of the Jews?”
Again, Pilate did not think Jesus was a king, and he didn’t think the Jews claimed him as their king. He’s mocking Jesus, and he’s probably subtly mocking the Jews.
But the Sanhedrin did not want Jesus released. So, Matthew 27:20 says, “The chief priests and the elders persuaded the crowds to ask for Barabbas and to put Jesus to death.” They obliged. “They cried out again, saying, ‘Not this Man, but Barabbas.’” The mob did not see King Jesus for who he was either.
Instead, they chose Barabbas. The obvious implication is that Jesus will die. John ends with a dramatic, tragic note, “Now Barabbas was a robber.” Mark adds, “Barabbas had been imprisoned with the insurrectionists who had committed murder in the insurrection” (Mark 15:7).
It’s terribly ironic. The Sanhedrin accused Jesus of treason then they persuaded the people to request a true traitor. Israel loved a murderer more than the Son of God.
Conclusion
John tells this tragic tale to warn you how not to respond to Jesus and to persuade you instead to honor Jesus as the sovereign king. It’s easy to criticize the Jews for preferring Barabbas, but you can be just as foolish if you choose your sin over Jesus. See the darkness for what it is, but especially see Jesus as the sovereign, good king. Jesus cared for Pilate, and he cares for you. Someday, he will judge the earth and reign as its king. You must be ready.
So, don’t be like Pilate. Pilate capitulated to the crowd. He feared man more than he feared Jesus, and it cost him his soul. Learn from his tragedy. Honor Jesus as the sovereign king. That begins with confessing Jesus as your Lord and receiving him as your Savior. We’d love to talk with you today about Christ can save you from your sins and make you his own. And Christian, every day you are confronted with choices like Pilot’s. Don’t capitulate to convenience. Bow to King Jesus then stand for King Jesus. Give clear witness to your faith in him. Take a strong stance against sin. Do what is right, not what is easy. Honor Jesus as the sovereign king.
other sermons in this series
Dec 14
2025
Friendship for a Lifetime
Pastor: Kit Johnson Passage: John 17:17 Series: John, After the Farewell Discourse
Nov 30
2025
Grief to Joy
Pastor: Kit Johnson Passage: John 20:11–18 Series: John, After the Farewell Discourse
Nov 16
2025
Believe in the Resurrection
Pastor: Kit Johnson Passage: John 20:1–10 Series: John, After the Farewell Discourse